How the Protocol Transparency Ratings (PTR) methodology works
The Protocol Transparency Ratings (PTR) methodology, developed by RockawayX, makes the disclosure quality of a published Proof of Solvency dashboard visible and comparable.
What the disclosure grade means
Measures a dashboard’s transparency
How complete, specific, current and independently checkable the public picture is for an allocator at the capture date.
Does not certify safety
The disclosure grade is not a safety score, credit rating, solvency guarantee, audit opinion or investment recommendation.
Unit of analysis and capture
The unit of analysis is a specific rendered dashboard at a specific moment. The rater archives the rendered page, screenshots and text, records the timestamp and methodology version, then checks supporting public evidence.
The framework analyzes a dashboard’s information, supported by public issuer documentation, to rate its transparency based on a checklist of 24 items across 9 dimensions. Unverifiable assertions are treated as claims, not verified evidence.
Capture
Archive the rendered dashboard, timestamp and methodology version.
Score 24 evidence items
Assign scores from 0 to 4 for each item, including half-points, and record the supporting evidence and reading.
Run cross-checks
Reproduce available supply and balances, inspect explorer links and record matches or contradictions.
Aggregate and apply gates
Calculate the nine dimension scores and the weighted total PTR score. Apply selectivity gates (critical transparency gaps that impact the grade) and translate the score into a grade from AAA to C.
Publish
Publish the disclosure grade, score, capture date, evidence, negative-space map (transparency gaps), recommendations, and disclaimer.
Item Scoring
Every item receives a numeric score based on captured evidence.
0
Absent
1
Ambiguous
2
Shown as a headline only
3
Shown in detail or independently attested
4
Reproduced / on-chain-verifiable
Half-points are allowed at tier boundaries. Item-level evidence is published because trained raters may differ by half a point and disagreement must stay inspectable.
Disclosure Grade Bands
The reference scale used to interpret composite scores, shown here and alongside every published rating.
- AAA3.60, 4.00
- Full risk assessment
- AA3.20, 3.60
- Near-complete; one notable gap
- A2.70, 3.20
- Strong; a few gaps
- BBB2.20, 2.70
- Adequate
- BB1.70, 2.20
- Limited; critical data missing
- B1.20, 1.70
- Weak; mostly headline figures
- C0, 1.20
- Black box
Calculation
The composite score is calculated as a weighted sum of scores across the 24 items, with the scoring scale ranging from 0.00 to 4.00. A disclosure grade is published based on the composite score (see table above), plus selectivity gates (critical transparency gaps) impact the final grade.
Selectivity gates
Gates can adjust or cap the disclosure grade after the base band is set. A gate can apply without changing the outcome, in which case it's shown as not binding.
Critical omission ceiling
Caps the maximum disclosure grade based on the number of critical omissions across 11 key items. Omission is defined as a score <=1. 1 critical omission: max BBB; 2 or more: max B. An omission of a medium-impact item (9 in total) caps at AA.
Mismatch downgrade
An unresolved contradiction between the dashboard and a primary source drops the disclosure grade one band, marked with a downward triangle.
Kill-switch flag
Appends a minus to the disclosure grade when the entire signal depends on one revocable external feed with no independent verification path.
Single-vendor cap
Caps the disclosure grade at BBB when no independent way exists to verify the data outside the platform itself.
Negative-space map
Each missing or contradictory item is flagged as critical, a mismatch, or a minor gap, with the reasoning and its impact on the disclosure grade shown alongside it. A withheld field can count as a reasonable trade-off if the reason is defensible and equivalent evidence exists elsewhere (legitimate non-disclosure).
Evidence-checking process
1 · On-chain reproduction
Recompute supply, reserves, ratios, balances and relevant contract controls.
2 · Attestation and custody trace
Trace off-chain positions to custody or attestation evidence.
3 · Adversarial check
Try to disprove strong claims and use the weaker reading when evidence is uncertain.
4 · Liveness and control
Inspect feed, oracle and key control, halt conditions and page failure behavior.
Public by default
Every eligible Proof of Solvency dashboard can be assessed using the public methodology. Publication policy, operator consent and the final public rating name remain governance decisions outside the scoring arithmetic.
Publication requirements and limitations
Each published rating includes the rater, methodology version, capture date, disclosure grade, dimension scores, supporting evidence, any gates applied, and dated sources.